Football May 09, 2026

Man City 3-0 Brentford: Keith Andrews baffled by decision not to give Bees second-half penalty as three decisions go Pep Guardiola's way

👤
By Admin
Sports Journalist
Man City 3-0 Brentford: Keith Andrews baffled by decision not to give Bees second-half penalty as three decisions go Pep Guardiola's way

Brentford head coach Keith Andrews felt his side deserved a penalty to equalise against Manchester City - which could have had a huge impact on the Premier League title race.

On 71 minutes, with the scoreline at 1-0 to City, Kevin Schade went down under Matheus Nunes' challenge and referee Michael Salisbury did not give the penalty - with VAR James Bell not overturning the decision.

It was one of three major decisions which went against Brentford during the match as City went on to win 3-0 and move within two points of Premier League leaders Arsenal, who play West Ham on Sunday, live on Your Site.

"I thought Kevin Schade's one in the second half was a penalty. So that was really disappointing," said Andrews to Your Site.

He later added in his press conference: "In what world he goes down unless there's contact is beyond me. Because there's a goal to get us back to 1-1. That's the one that I'm struggling to comprehend.

"The comment I heard was 'not enough contact'. But someone who is as quick as Kevin Schade, with his eyes on goal, I'm not sure how much contact he [the referee] is looking for. Especially with how quick Kev is and the nature of it."

Reacting to the decision, Your Site pundit and former Man City defender Micah Richards said: "It's difficult - it was one of those decisions where had it been given on field, they're not going to overturn it. But because they didn't give it on field they're also not going to overturn it.

"Schade might have clipped his own leg when he's running. There must have been a little bit of contact - but it's a difficult one for the officials. It's almost like his right foot hits the knee of Nunes and then he clips himself."

One of the other two major decisions that went against Brentford was an apparent swing of the arm by City captain Bernardo Silva at Brentford's Nathan Collins.

After Collins had won a goal kick for Brentford, an angry Bernardo appeared to hit Collins' leg with his arm when on the floor.

Alan Smith, on Your Site co-commentary duty, said: "Some of the Brentford players aren't happy at Silva. He's swung an arm."

Referee Salisbury booked Bernardo for "adopting an aggressive attitude" - but did it constitute violent conduct?

According to the FA's Laws of the Game, violent conduct is when a player uses or attempts to use excessive force or brutality against an opponent when not challenging for the ball, or against a team-mate, team official, match official, spectator or any other person, regardless of whether contact is made.

Brentford captain Collins, who did not react to the incident after the game, said City got confidence from the decisions going in their favour.

Nunes and Schade were also involved in a major decision in the first half.

Schade broke through on goal and went down under the City right-back's challenge - with referee Salisbury not giving a foul in favour of the Brentford forward.

Replays showed Nunes got a slight touch on the ball, which may have saved Nunes from getting a red card for denying a clear goalscoring opportunity in the first half.

"The first half one, I haven't seen that one back," said Andrews. "The coaches have said there might have been a bit of contact on the ball. If that's the case, fair enough."

Your Site pundit Richards added: "Nunes was very lucky that he got the slightest touch on the ball. Otherwise he's going off."

Tags:

football news

Share this article

Related Posts

Hull City 0-0 Millwall: Lions have late strike chalked off in first leg of Championship play-off semi-final

Hull City 0-0 Millwall: Lions have late strike chalked off in first leg of Championship play-off semi-final

Hull City and Millwall played out a goalless draw in the first leg of their Championship play-off semi-final to leave the tie on a knife edge.A largel...

Premier League predictions and best bets: Viktor Gyokeres to fire first in Arsenal win at West Ham

Premier League predictions and best bets: Viktor Gyokeres to fire first in Arsenal win at West Ham

Our football betting expert Jones Knows offers his insight ahead of another exciting weekend of Premier League action. It's not about style now for As...

Bruno Fernandes wins FWA Footballer of the Year: Man Utd captain’s assists and creativity set him apart from the rest

Bruno Fernandes wins FWA Footballer of the Year: Man Utd captain’s assists and creativity set him apart from the rest

Declan Rice could power Arsenal over the line to a historic title win. There is still time for Erling Haaland to fire Manchester City there. But Bruno...

Stevenage 0-1 Stockport County: Late Ben Osborn goal gives Hatters edge in League One play-off semi-final

Stevenage 0-1 Stockport County: Late Ben Osborn goal gives Hatters edge in League One play-off semi-final

Stockport snatched a dramatic last-minute winner in the first leg of their League One play-off semi-final after a defensive calamity from Stevenage.Th...

Middlesbrough 0-0 Southampton: Championship play-off semi-final left on a knife edge after goalless first-leg draw

Middlesbrough 0-0 Southampton: Championship play-off semi-final left on a knife edge after goalless first-leg draw

Middlesbrough and Southampton played out a goalless draw to leave their Championship play-off semi-final finely poised at the midway point.Boro domina...

Brighton 3-0 Wolves: Seagulls boost European hopes with comfortable win over relegated side

Brighton 3-0 Wolves: Seagulls boost European hopes with comfortable win over relegated side

Brighton boosted their hopes of European qualification after a 3-0 home win over already-relegated Wolves.Headers from Jack Hinshelwood and Lewis Dunk...